Talk to Franz

SEO · 09

SEO Agency Cleanup Consulting.

Underwater, a man tears layers of old papers off a wooden noticeboard on the seabed; the scraps float away to the surface and a clean board with three cards on green pins appears underneath
AI-generated image (OpenAI, via Codex) for Full Stack Optimization

Several agencies, audits and tools later, nobody has the whole picture. I test every claim against your own data, keep what works, remove what hurts and hand your team one list.

You hire me when

  • You doubt your agency's audit or its results.
  • An agency report blames Google, and nobody in house can check it.
  • Several agencies worked on the site and nobody has the full picture.
  • You pay for SEO tools and nobody knows who uses them.

What you get

  • Every claim in your agency reports, tested against your own Search Console data.
  • An inventory of what the agencies changed: redirects, tags, markup, tools, contracts.
  • Keep, fix, remove: one list with owners and an order.
  • The fixes, specified for your developers or done with them.
  • A handover with checks your team runs without me and without a tool subscription.

Why agency work needs a cleanup

Every agency leaves something behind: a report, redirects, markup, a tool contract. Each one made sense to someone once. Years later, nobody owns the sum.

Google’s own advice on hiring an SEO names the risk plainly: you can improve your visibility, “but you can also risk damage to your site and reputation.” (Google Search Central, Do you need an SEO?)

My goal in every cleanup: you understand your own site again. Every claim tested, every leftover with an owner, and one list your team can work from.

What I found after agencies in 2026

This is what I found in 2026 when I checked what agencies, audits and tools had left behind, and what I specified instead:

What breaksWhat I measuredWhat I specify
The report measures a model, not your clicksThe named root cause explained about 0 percent of the lossClicks from Search Console, every row, before any verdict
Changes nobody loggedProduction changes from the agency reports, missing from the release logOne release log; every SEO change gets a date and an owner
A canonical tag over the real faultAbout 6k canonicalised pages still linked from the siteFix the links at the source; the canonical stays a failsafe
The right fixes in the wrong orderThe sitemap fix last on the list, while the sitemap listed under 2 percent of known URLsSitemap first, then what depends on it
Redirects nobody ownsAbout 1 in 5 old URLs redirect; gone products end on the home pageOne flat map, a 410 for what is gone, an owner and a date on every rule
A relaunch drops the structured dataThe relaunch removed the structured dataArticle, BreadcrumbList, Organization, checked in Google’s Rich Results Test
Tools nobody ownsA tool contract still running, and nobody sure who pays for it or uses itSearch Console first; cancel what it already covers

The report measures a model, not your clicks

The agency’s analysis blamed the traffic loss on a change to the indexing rules for one page type. It measured a visibility index.

  • I tested the claim on every row of the Search Console data.
  • The change was real. While it ran, it cost at most about 0.3 percent of clicks.
  • Its share of the loss: about 0 percent. It was the state before the loss, not its cause.

A visibility index and an AI tracker said one thing, the clicks another. My rule for that team: “Tool scores are simulations.” Search Console measures reality.

What I specify: clicks from Search Console are the primary metric. No verdict before every row is checked.

Changes nobody logged

The agency’s second report listed one of its own recommendations as “already done”. No date.

  • Several production changes were named in the agency reports and missing from the client’s release log.
  • All of them fell in or just before the traffic drop.
  • I dated the indexing change from the data instead: to within days.

What I specify: one release log for every change that touches SEO, whoever makes it. Date, what changed, who owns it.

A canonical tag over the real fault

The audit’s quick fix for internal links with campaign parameters: put a canonical tag on every variant. The same audit counted about 6k canonicalised pages that the site still linked to.

My verdict to the team: “Canonical is a mini failsafe against unknown URL variations, not a fix for internal linking.”

The agency’s spec left the canonical empty for page 2 and for the filter pages. The classic way to fill it, a canonical from page 2 to page 1, costs exactly the products listed only on page 2.

What I specify: no links to non-canonical URLs. Campaign parameters are for external campaigns, never for internal links. Every page gets a self-referencing canonical, page 2 included.

The right fixes in the wrong order

The audit put the sitemap last: first clean up indexing and canonicals. But the sitemap listed under 2 percent of the pages Google knew. The main sitemap file had the wrong format, and Search Console counted 0 indexed from it.

The audit was a good task list. What was missing: shared responsibility, goals and processes. My order: mindset, setup, goals, processes, tasks. As I put it in the review: “A process is worth a 1000 tasks.”

What I specify: the sitemap first, submitted and checked. Then the fixes that depend on Google finding the pages.

Redirects nobody owns

The old platform had piled up redirects over the years.

  • About 1 in 5 sampled URLs answered with a 301.
  • Products that were gone ended on the home page: a soft 404 Googlebot keeps recrawling.
  • One endpoint took about 40 percent of Googlebot’s requests.

Instead of a full one-to-one mapping, I ranked the old URLs by clicks. A handful of rule groups move about 90 percent of the clicks. The rest is a short list a person reviews.

What I specify: at launch, all old redirects go. One flat map, one hop. A 410 for what is gone. Every new redirect rule gets an owner, a reason and a date.

A relaunch drops the structured data

The old site carried structured data on every page. The relaunch removed it, and with it the machine-readable publication date.

Google: “Google uses structured data that it finds on the web to understand the content of the page”. (Google Search Central, Intro to structured data)

What I specify: one template with the three types Google supports for this page: Article, BreadcrumbList, Organization. The visible date and the date in the markup match. No FAQ markup, no llms.txt.

Tools nobody owns

  • A tool contract was still running, and nobody was sure who held it, who paid for it or what it was used for. If it mostly does rank tracking, Search Console covers that.
  • Another tool on the list no longer exists as a product.
  • My own analysis for the meeting used no SEO tool subscription at all. The only paid input, raw search result data for about 50 queries, cost under 10 cents.

What I specify: Search Console and your own logs first. A contract without an owner and without a use gets cancelled.

How I clean up

  1. Data first, reports last. I pull your Search Console data and crawl the site before I read the agency’s slides. In one case I asked for the release log before the existing analyses.
  2. Every claim gets a test. Each statement in a report becomes a row: claim, source, my measurement, verdict. In one audit, a headline number about the home page was wrong in the full Search Console window. Several statements needed a correction. I still called the audit “overall solid and honestly calibrated”.
  3. Keep, fix, remove. One list, every item with an owner and an order. In one relaunch: over 30 open questions, about a third of my answers differed from the agency’s plan, and a handful were decisions only the client could make.
  4. At the table with the agency. In a dry run of one meeting, a slide of mine read as an accusation. I replaced it: everything is a proposal until we agree on it. The problems shown were the old platform’s, not the agency’s.
  5. Process before tasks. One gate instead of a thousand tickets. In one project: every page under 150 KB of unzipped HTML, or it does not go live.
  6. A handover your team can check. The last section of one of my 2026 decks: how to check every step yourself, without me and without a tool subscription.

This site, cleaned up in 2026

On 21 October 2026 I moved this site from WordPress to static. The old sitemaps listed about 40 URLs. Three were the cart, checkout and account pages of an old shop plugin.

Those three now answer a short, deliberate 404. Try one. Old WordPress thumbnail URLs redirect to their original image in one hop: try this one. The full migration is on the relaunch SEO page.

Questions I get before a cleanup

Do we have to fire our agency?

No. Most of what I find is nobody’s fault: it is what is left when several teams worked on one site over years. Often the agency stays, and works from the cleaned-up list.

What access do you need?

Read access is enough to start. Google’s own advice for any SEO audit: “only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don’t grant them write access).” (source)

What should a good audit give us?

Google: “An SEO audit should be about giving you realistic estimates of improvement, and an estimate of the work involved.” (source) I add an owner and an order for every item.

Our agency promises rankings. Can it?

No. Google: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” (source)

Do we need SEO tool subscriptions?

Usually fewer than you pay for. Visibility indexes and AI trackers model reality. Search Console measures it.

How long does it take?

A project of a few weeks, fixed scope and price. If an agency report blames Google for a traffic loss, start with search data and traffic forensics.

Sources for the Google quotes on this page, read on 2026-10-24: Do you need an SEO? and Intro to structured data, Google Search Central. The client numbers come from my own audits, workshops and handovers in 2026.

From real jobs

  • 2026: two agency traffic analyses tested against every row of Search Console data; the root cause they named explained about 0 percent of the loss.
  • 2026: a central team's traffic-drop analysis rechecked, a tool contract without an owner, structured data the relaunch had removed.
  • 2026: a relaunch agency's spec reviewed, its open questions answered, the old redirects replaced by one map.
  • 2026: a long SEO audit reviewed and put in a new order.
  • A fintech: paid media agency governance.